Here’s a Tofukuji pot that I picked up last month, and even after staring at it for a month, I’m at a loss as to whether it is a first or second generation. The glaze, patina, method of attachment for the feet, clay type, and both chops are all First generation Heian Tofukuji(although Jr often didn’t mark his pots as second generation). The only detail that points to it being a second generation Tofukuji is the depth of the smaller chop to the left, which is uncommon for First generation Tofukuji(though I have seen a couple), but very common for Second generation. It measures 4.5″ by 4″ by 1.5″.
Either way, it’s really just a matter of value, as it’s an awesome pot with awesome patina any way you look at it. If it is a second generation, it’s probably the best example I’ve seen of Kiln changed glaze work from Jr. The pot is hand formed, and has some fingerprints left in the clay….perhaps….
The only other Tofukuji I’ve seen with a similiar glaze, a first generation from the Hatanaka book.
Very nice pot but the price difference between a first and second gen pot is large. I don’t think I would have purchased a tofo without knowing for sure what gen it was. Hope you paid gen two price for a gen one pot! great blog site.
As I said in the blog, the only two things that indicate it may be a Jr are that the kanji chop is too deep, and I bought it as a Jr. Upper level Jr price to be sure, but worth it either way.