An ID Mystery, Solved

A couple of years ago I purchased a pot from Toriumi on eBay that neither he nor I could identify(actually a LOT of pots, this one just happened to remain so!). I asked all my friends in Japan, checked the books: no dice.
Knowing what I know now, I’m surprised I did not see it sooner, but since I bought it the pot has been languishing on one of my back benches with a small clump of hackberry, gaining some patina: out of sight, out of mind.
My friend Keiichi Hanaori translated the signature for me, “山水作”-“San Sui made”. And surmised that it was perhaps a description, rather than a potter, as it is a mountain and water scene(San-mountain, Sui-water).
Now, the pot.

20130105-083700.jpg
And the nail signature:

20130105-083739.jpg
I look through literally thousands of pots weekly for sale, and hadn’t come across another “Sansui” until this morning.

20130105-084012.jpg

20130105-084023.jpg
In the item description, the seller gives no information about the potter…but says he bought it from Bigei at his studio in Tokoname 30 years ago…Duh.
After looking closely at the pot, and going back and taking a look at my pot, that’s all I needed to know: the pots are definitely Bigei made.

20130105-090121.jpg
An identically shaped Bigei to the first “Sansui”. Note the, uh, identicalness of it. Right down to the root lines inside.

20130105-092332.jpg

20130105-092340.jpg
Two images of a carved Bigei in an identical style and shape to the second “Sansui”. Note the feet, shape, and inset recess and placement of the tie down holes on the underside are all the same as the round “Sansui.”

Looking at these images, it’s pretty obvious these are Bigei made pots, but are they painted by Bigei as well, thus making “Sansui” just a pseudonym Bigei uses for painted pots?

20130105-092636.jpg
Note the small hut nestled into the hills in the bottom right image, which when turned clockwise becomes the boat and rower in the upper left image.

20130105-093008.jpg
Another Bigei carved landscape with an identical motif: thatched hut nestled into the hills with a boat to the right.
The style of the pair of small boats to the upper right of the first “Sansui”, in appearance, spacing, and proportion, are identical to the pair on this piece:

20130105-093521.jpg
And the design of the open pagoda on the first “Sansui” is also cut of the same cloth as this piece:

20130105-093702.jpg
Not by any means 100% conclusive, it’s entirely possible that Bigei designed the scenes and commissioned someone else to paint them, but, given that the lone signature was carved by the maker of the pot, which is definitively Bigei, and not painted, and the fact that Bigei has no small talent in landscape scenes with a nail, I think it’s pretty clear that Bigei both made and painted these pots.

So, there you have it. An interesting little mystery wrapped up. Bigei is Sansui, and vice versa. Although these Bigei landscape painting pots have their own charm, its clear that Bigei’s talents lie more in carving and burnishing than landscape painting, but perhaps that’s the point of the pseudonym?
Thanks for reading!

Advertisements

About japanesepots

I've been collecting Japanese Bonsai pots for a few years, and feel that the famous, and some of the lesser known but great Japanese pot artists could do with a little more writing and exposure in English. Additionally, this blog will feature My own And others bonsai for discussion. The purpose of this blog is to further knowledge of Japanese pottery and Japanese style bonsai. If you have any questions about Japanese bonsai pottery, or would like to acquire pots by some of the potters presented in the blog, feel free to email me at gastrognome@aol.com
This entry was posted in Modern Potters, My Personal Collection, Pot Info, ID, Hanko, Books, ect.. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to An ID Mystery, Solved

  1. Mark says:

    Very cool.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s